Lead Pastor

A graduate of Dallas Theological Seminary, Paul spent just over a decade doing ministry in the land of Longhorns & Cowboys before moving to the Philly area in 2010 to take on the role of our lead pastor. Paul is an incurable coffee drinker and avid reader. His wife Jenny, and kids, Jillian & Caleb, are a great source of joy (& sermon illustrations).

Executive Director

Erik has attended our church since 2006 but spent nearly 20 years as an engineer before being called in 2019 to serve as Executive Director and lead New Story's staff. Erik is married to Patti; they have three children (Abigail, Lucy, & Sam) and three pet rabbits. He loves to read, play games, hike, and eat Zwahlen's ice cream.

Pastor of Spiritual Formation & Community Life

Dave is a graduate of Denver Seminary where his penchant for reading was quite useful. Though he misses those majestic Rocky Mountains, he still enjoys the outdoors via hiking, backpacking, camping...and birding whenever he can. Dave and Erin have three cute kids (Carden, Jude, and Esmé) that seem to age him at a far greater rate than he desires.

Kids Ministry Director

As a graduate from Westminster Theological Seminary and a long-time kids ministry volunteer, Betsey loves combining her love of Scripture and her connection with kids to create age-appropriate and Gospel-centered programs. In her free time, Betsey enjoys hiking in Valley Forge with her husband Robert and their two children, Selah and Jack.

Worship Leader

Heather has been part of the worship team since 2013, but has been playing piano since the age of five and leading worship for over 20 years in various settings. Heather and her husband, Chuck, live in Phoenixville with their 3 children. She is a lover of Broadway, Dunkin iced tea, Penn State, her dogs, and helping others worship through music.

Communications Manager

Hannah joined the team right out of college and has a passion for creatively communicating all that God is doing at New Story. She resides in West Chester with her husband, Ryan, and world's cutest pup, Murphy. In her free time, Hannah enjoys singing show tunes, tending to her house plants, and talking about the books she’s currently reading.

Executive Assistant to Lead Pastor

Patty is a master of organization who learned all of her tricks as a mom of 5 and military spouse to Joe. After 25 years in the army and 17 moves, they have retired from military life and landed in Phoenixville. In her spare time, Patty helps her husband build next-level tree houses and enjoys all kinds of outdoor fun with her family.

Finance Administrator

Eamon has been involved in church finance for over 10 years. He lives in Sanatoga with his wife Sarah and their three children, Mairen, Gwyneth, and Rhys. He really enjoys a good cup of brewed coffee; “Fratalian” is his own special mix. Eamon enjoys listening and playing along to music, and serves on the worship team monthly.

AV Director

As a sound engineer by trade, Clint runs the technical side of things at New Story. He also runs Philamedia, with his twin brother. He lives in Brewerytown, Philadelphia with his wife, Ally and son, Sol. Clint spends his free time blurring the line between what he does for work and fun, because they’re pretty much the same thing.

Video Specialist

A filmmaker based out of Philadelphia and New York, Nico oversees all video production at New Story. Outside New Story, he also professionally directs and produces commercials, film, and television content. Nico enjoys running, reading, playing & watching hockey, and traveling with his wife, Sarah. His talented cat, Finch, can sit, stand, and high-five on command.

Logistics Specialist

After teaching in the public school system for 17 years, Lillian decided it was time for a change. She began volunteering in the kids ministry and tear down team and now works part-time for the church. In her free time, Lillian enjoys playing and watching sports, going to the beach and spending time with her husband A.J. and four children.

Kids Ministry Administration

Lisa and her husband moved to the Phoenixville area in 2021. She loves being a stay at home mom to her 3 boys and dog. Her greatest joy is spending time with her family outdoors.

20’s Ministry

Wendy & Bob lead the 20s ministry with whom they have dinner every Tuesday! They have 6 daughters, 3 son-in-laws, 4 grandchildren and a dog. Bob is an Actuary and Wendy is a HS Math Teacher. They love being with the 20s, learning with them, serving in the community with them and experiencing life together.

Womens Ministry

Michelle has been involved in Women’s Ministry for over 25 years. The best that she’s learned about being a women of God, wife, mother and friend she’s learned through the women she’s been in Christian community with. She leads with these gifted women: Anne, Kate, Laura, Lisa, Lori, Pam, Patti, & Sarah.

Lamplighters Ministry